Tips & advice
Why we rank cows on milksolids per kg of liveweight
Cow —: kgMS ÷ liveweight = ratio
A big cow that makes a lot of milk isn't always a good cow. The better question is how much milk she makes for the body she has to feed.
In the shed at milking, the cows that catch your eye are the big ones. They fill the bail, they fill the vat, and on a herd test sheet their milksolids look great. But every one of those extra kilograms of cow has to be fed every day of the year, whether she's milking or not.
That's why Cube ranks every cow on one number first: her season's milksolids divided by her average liveweight. It's the measure one of us has judged cows by for years, and once you see a herd laid out this way, it's hard to go back.
Feed goes to the body first
A cow spends a big share of what she eats just keeping herself going: walking to the shed, staying warm, carrying her own frame. Only what's left over becomes milk. The heavier she is, the more feed she needs just to stand still. So if a big cow isn't making proportionally more milk, she's eating grass that a lighter, more efficient cow would have turned into milksolids.
Raw milksolids hide that. Liveweight on its own hides it too. Put the two together, as in the chart above, and the picture changes: the dashed lines are 1.00, 1.25 and 1.50 kgMS per kg. Every cow above a line beats it. Many farmers use a cow producing her own liveweight in milksolids, a ratio of 1.00, as the line to beat.
Three cows, one question
Here are three made-up cows. On milksolids alone, A and B tie and C comes last. Now divide by what each one weighs.
SEASON kgMS
kgMS PER kg OF LIVEWEIGHT
A (480 kg) and B (560 kg) both make 600 kgMS. C weighs 400 kg and makes 520. Ranked on the ratio, C is best and B, the biggest cow in the paddock, is last. B isn't a bad cow. She's just an expensive way to make 600 kgMS.
How your herd spreads out
Lay a whole herd out on the ratio and you get a spread like this one. Most cows sit in the middle. The two ends are where the decisions are.
The right-hand tail is the cows carrying the herd: worth breeding replacements from. The left-hand tail is where to look first when you're deciding who to cull or dry off early.
Why not just milksolids per cow?
Because milksolids per cow rewards size. A herd ranked on raw milk drifts towards bigger cows over the years, and bigger cows need more feed, more space and more pasture to carry them. The ratio rewards the cow that does the most with what she's given.
And per hectare?
Milksolids per hectare is a great measure of the farm. It tells you nothing about which cow to keep. The ratio is the cow-level answer to the same question: how well does this farm turn grass into milk?
How Cube works it out
The number is only worth having if you can trust it, so Cube is fussy about what goes in:
- The season is June to May. Milksolids come from the herd records for that season.
- Liveweight is the average of her own weigh-ins in that season, from your walk-over scales or collars. She needs at least three before Cube gives her a figure.
- Only readings that are really hers count. If an export has been copied twice, or a reading can't be tied to her, it's dropped, and Cube tells you why.
- A cow is a cow, not a number. Ear-tag numbers get reused when cows leave. Cube ties every cow to her birth ID, so a heifer given an old number doesn't inherit the old cow's record.
- No weigh-ins, no figure. A first calver who hasn't been weighed enough gets a gap, not a guess.
Every step is a list you can open in Cube: the cows that left, the numbers that were reused, the cows without enough weigh-ins. Nobody disappears without a reason.
Her average is worked out from her own readings only. A reading that turns out to be a copy of an earlier export is crossed out and left out, and the reason is written next to it.
Every cow shows her working
Open any cow in Cube and you see the sum behind her figure, for example 600 kgMS ÷ 480 kg = 1.25, every weigh-in that was used and every one that was dropped, and where each number came from."If there's something that I'm interested in here, if I click on it, that will drill down to the source of truth."Phil · Dairy farmer
Read it with the rest of her story
No single number should make a culling decision for you, and this one doesn't try to. A few things to keep in mind:
- First calvers are still growing. Compare them with other first calvers, not with mature cows.
- Late calvers have had fewer days to milk. Cube shows her days in milk next to her ratio, so a late calver isn't judged on a short season.
- Health and fertility still matter. Cell count, in-calf status and age sit on the same page as her ratio.
Cube also shows each cow in dollars: her milk income less an equal share of the farm's costs, with animal health counted. We're careful to call that what it is, and not "profit", because the books don't record costs cow by cow. Milksolids per kg of liveweight doesn't have that problem. It comes straight from what she made and what she weighs.
See your own herd this way
If you herd test and weigh your cows, the numbers to do this already exist. They're just in two different places. Cube puts them together, cow by cow, and keeps it up to date as new weigh-ins come in.
Book a walkthrough and we'll show you what it looks like on a farm like yours.